Advanced Search

Please click here to take a brief survey

Place, Space, Words
Alex Steffen, 12 Sep 04

Making buildings is one of the most important things we do. Buildings have defining cultural impacts. Their construction and operation stamp giant ecological footprints into the planet. They are some of our longest-lived creations, right up there with landfills, extinctions and nuclear waste. We cannot change the world without changing what and how we build.

To change anything intelligently, though, we must first see it. Seeing buildings and places in a fresh way is the job of the architectural critic.

But architectural criticism is, by all accounts, a trade in crisis.

The latest issue of Arcade magazine (which for some reason is not yet up on their site) has a superb section exploring the state of architectural criticism in the US.

Meanwhile, the excellent Project for Public Spaces has posted a sort of roll-your-own guide to architectural criticism and the evaluation of public spaces:

Tips on being a do-it-yourself critic

Have a Sense of Entitlement. Designing buildings may be incredibly difficult, but understanding them comes naturally if you let your own judgment lead you. Feel entitled to have your say, because most people who use buildings are not professional critics.

Be Self-Conscious. Observe yourself using the building. Does finding your way around feel intuitive? Do certain areas make you feel exhilarated, others frustrated or confused? Discern why specific elements of the building elicit such reactions.

Stare at Others. Public buildings especially should be able to handle large volumes of people. Look at how other people react to the building. Can they comfortably engage in activities common to public spaces, such as conversing with others, sitting down for a spell, or waiting for friends to arrive?

Gossip. When you've formed an opinion about a place, share it with people! The greatest service that professional critics have done is to popularize discussions about architecture. People with a passion for public spaces need to make their voices heard, whether it be at the dinner table, in the office, at a bar, or on the web

Bookmark and Share


Travel. E.g. see how buildings are constructed in Switzerland. Built, it seems, to last for several hundred years. And individualized - each house, and especially each public building, can be distinctive while integrating into a harmonious whole. The bomb shelters in basements in case of disaster are a bonus...

Posted by: Hassan on 13 Sep 04

It just so happens that yesterday I made a photo-'blog about a visit to Seattle's Central Library.

There were lots of people with digital cameras, myself included, wandering around the library on a Sunday, most of them doing the things you list.

Posted by: Paul on 13 Sep 04



MESSAGE (optional):

Search Worldchanging

Worldchanging Newsletter Get good news for a change —
Click here to sign up!


Website Design by Eben Design | Logo Design by Egg Hosting | Hosted by Amazon AWS | Problems with the site? Send email to tech /at/
Architecture for Humanity - all rights reserved except where otherwise indicated.

Find_us_on_facebook_badge.gif twitter-logo.jpg