By Anisa Baldwin Metzger
Four years after Hurricane Katrina ravaged the Gulf Coast, the struggle to rebuild continues. In the days after the 2005 storm, when the levees were breached in several locations, about 80 percent of the city was flooded. While the area is going through a painful recovery, it is giving everyone lesson after lesson on how to undertake such a massive effort.
It’s no surprise that the volume of rebuilding activity is high: federal funds are pouring in for just this purpose. The surprise is how that volume is playing out, through small organizations who are daring enough to allow for experimentation and who know the value of strong partnerships. This network of non-profits and start-ups is taking on the daunting challenge of rebuilding while respecting the identity and character of a place so rich with history.
You might think, as I did, that what New Orleans really needs is a couple of large contractors dedicated to building back large swaths of the city, repairing what can be repaired and rebuilding what needs to be rebuilt. We want to get people back in safe, solid homes, and there is ample frustration at how long everything takes to get done in the city. On top of the issue of slowness, the reality is that large companies are usually better able to invest time in research and development and therefore to foster innovation. But it seems that the community of small players that has risen out of the recovery process is not only making residents and local business-owners feel more like a part of the rebuilding process but is also allowing support and room for growth within the building industry in a way that would not be possible in a larger-scale operation.
Local groups have also been willing to engage with the community, generating results that preserve city character and serve needs specific to New Orleans. Across town from the Make It Right project, a growing group of individuals has been assembled by The Salvation Army to work on building 125 green, affordable homes and renovating 125 existing homes in a program called EnviRenew. They’re working closely with two neighborhood development corporations; and they’re convening architects, real estate agents, sustainability consultants, financing authorities and other local professionals to come up with a way to rebuild homes for targeted populations like the elderly, teachers and first responders with small families. Like other small rebuilding projects, the collaboration of players is key. By bringing neighborhood representatives together with building professionals, the group is demonstrating that lengthy engagement with a community can bring about results that are best for all involved. Through the neighborhood development corporations, they’ve gained community support for the acquisition of lots and the plans for the new homes. When the group wants to make a decision about how the program will proceed, they often draw together a quick focus group of residents to guide progress. The manageable scale of the project allows both the immediate community and local building professionals to participate, so — in the larger picture — the city can be fully participatory in its own rebuilding.
Hundreds of organizations are trying to come up with effective solutions that will not only work for New Orleans but will also provide templates for whatever may be the next international disaster. The best result, as EnviRenew development consultant Will Bradshaw says, “would be if we do figure out, out of all this messiness, and in many different ways, how to package all of this for use elsewhere, in other places that may need it.” The biggest relief organizations in the world are still learning from the successes and failures of their response to Hurricane Katrina. The City’s preparation and evacuation for Hurricane Gustav in 2008 was, by all accounts, miles ahead of what was done to prepare for Hurricane Katrina. But many of the most successful and creative solutions are being carried out by smaller-scale operations that allow room for experimentation, pull in neighborhood groups and local businesses, and partner with a wide variety of the city’s many non-profits and start-ups. It may not be the fastest, or even the cheapest, way to get stuff built, but New Orleanians don’t want just ‘stuff.’ They want a built environment that reflects and serves well the city’s funky, lilting, jumbled identity. And that takes some creativity.
Anisa Baldwin Metzger is the U.S. Green Building Council's New Orleans Green Building Coordinator. She holds degrees in architecture from Washington University in St. Louis and the University of Washington in Seattle. With some dedicated Seattle architects, she helped start the city's Architecture for Humanity chapter, a group that combats the problems of homelessness and poverty through design and construction of socially responsible structures. In her current position in New Orleans, she focuses on the implementation of LEED standards in the Recovery School District's new schools and major renovations as well as on the support of current efforts to green the RSD's existing schools.
Top photo credit: www.nola.com.
Thank you Ms. Baldwin Metzger for telling the story right, for pointing out in the first paragraph, that in New Orleans the levees breached. This distinction is critically important. America needs to understand that distinction, and how the responsibility for those levee breach failures belonged to THEIR Army Corps of Engineers.
Inspiring article. It's good to see that the rebuilding stages are going well.
Reading this makes my heart sing.
Great post on the slow pace of rebuilding New Orleans. I volunteered with NOLA Habitat for Humanity in Musician's Village 2.5 years after Hurricane Katrina hit and was surprised how far New Orleans still had to go in the rebuilding process. Actually, clean up was still in progress as there was ruble scattered throughout the city and gutted houses still standing. And lack of power in some areas of town made using power tools difficult. Amazing to learn how far they still have to go in rebuilding 4 years after Katrina hit. Great post.