By Daniel Flahiff
Four thousand acres of private land in the Mojave desert are slated to become the site of an ambitious new concentrating solar power (CSP) plant: Hualapai Valley Solar (HVS). Named one of the Top 100 US Strategic Infrastructure Projects by CG/LA Infrastructure LLC, HVS is expected to produce 340MW of electricity, provide hundreds of new jobs and attract new business to the local area.There's only one problem — water.
HVS will consume an estimated 800 million gallons of water each year, placing significant pressure on the local aquifer. According to an article in the Kingman Daily Miner:
...the water issue may remain a substantial hurdle for HVS in the coming months, since the Mohave County General Plan states that the county will only approve power plants using air-based "dry cooling" technology when the aquifer is threatened with depletion or subsidence. An advisor to the project, Chris Stephens, has maintained that the aquifer holds more than enough water to accommodate the next century's worth of growth.
In a bold move to keep the project alive, the nearby city of Kingman, Ariz. has agreed to explore the possibility of providing treated city wastewater to help power and cool the project's steam turbines. Kingman will explore the feasibility of delivering "treated effluent" from its Hilltop Wastewater Treatment Plant to the HVS site. Preliminary estimates show that the city could provide more than half of the water that HVS will require. If the numbers pencil and the water issues can be resolved in a timely manner, HVS hopes to begin construction in November 2010 and open for operations by June 2013.
While the treated effluent cooling solution is to be commended, HVS would still put significant pressure on the local aquifer even after using all the city wastewater. We wonder if there is another possible solution to the turbine cooling problem. This situation highlights the desert southwest's resource allocation dilemma: an abundance of one resource, solar energy, and a scarcity of another required to harvest it, water.
And the water issue is not going away. Scientists at Scripps Institution of Oceanography last year forecast that "within 13 years Lake Mead and Lake Powell along the Colorado River, the two largest reservoirs in the southwest United States, could become 'dead pool' mud puddles." (Read more in Alex Steffen's recent feature, Dead Pool.) In our haste to develop subsidized, renewable energy resources are we losing sight of the bigger picture?
We'll be keeping an eye on HVS here at Worldchanging. Each new, renewable energy project that comes online puts us one step closer to a carbon neutral world. To do this while preserving and protecting our planet's fragile ecosystem is real, sustainable change, and that's change worth celebrating.
HVS current site overlay
HVS solar trough
HVS technology diagram
Daniel Flahiff is a writer, designer and filmmaker based in Seattle. He is a co-founder of Big Fig Design Group, a multi-disciplinary group of artists, designers and roustabouts who like to make all sorts of things. Daniel’s film and video work has been screened at the Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology, the Los Angeles Times Media Center, and at the 2000 Telluride International Experimental Cinema Exposition. His essays, interviews and criticism has appeared in Inhabitat and (incli)NATION.
Photo credits: flickr/mitchell.dong, © All rights reserved.
Does anyone have a detailed cost of this size project? We are looking at developing a similar size project in Kenya, and would great at this time if we had some good numbers to work with.
The one being built near Gila Bend, Arizona (also a parabolic mirror facility) is said to cost around $1 billion. This plant is 280kW, as opposed to the Hualpai facility which is 340kW.
A certain percentage of this cost is for local labor and contracting prices, which are probably high relative to Kenya?
I understand that Hualpai Valley Solar is running into issues with the local tribal entities. This plant is designed on the southeast shores of Red Lake (it appears as a dry lake bed in photo). Although usually dry, this place has cultural significance to the local tribal nation (Hualpai Nation).
I really hope they can work this out and build it! There are surely archaeological sites out there, but any adverse effect this project would have on them can be mitigated through excavation and reporting.
this project utilizes HUGE AMOUNTS of groundwater which the Kingman Community depends entirely on as their water supply! The small amount of effluent that Hualapai Valley SOlar CLAIMS they will use is SMALL compared to their total use. You should really do far more research before you print these kinds of outragous claims!